Amazon.co.uk Widgets
MyHomeSelection, a community-backed site, may earn a commission from purchases via our links. Learn more here.

Toaster Buying Guide

Published by: Maria Kelley • Updated: January 12, 2024 • Checked By: Chef Matty Riedel

The perfect toaster can elevate your morning routine, transforming a mundane task into a delightful experience. But with an overwhelming array of options available, how do you find the ideal toast-maker to suit your needs and preferences? My ultimate toaster buying guide is here to help. I’ll explore the key features you should consider, ranging from type and size to special functions and aesthetics, to ensure that your perfect toaster is just a few clicks away.

Key Features To Consider When Buying a Toaster

Various types of toasters on a kitchen counter

Searching for the perfect toaster involves examining various features that may influence your toasting experience. Considering factors like:

  • Type
  • Size
  • Slot width
  • Browning control
  • Material
  • Build quality
  • Special features
  • Ease of cleaning
  • Brand
  • Price
  • Safety features
  • Energy efficiency
  • Aesthetics

This guide will put you on the right track to finding the best toaster for achieving the perfect toast with your toast bread and introduce you to the best toasters on the market to suit your needs.

I will detail these 10 key features, giving examples and insights to help you choose wisely when buying your new toaster.

1. Type

When selecting a toaster, you must first choose a two-slice, four-slice, or touchscreen model. Two-slice toasters are well-suited for individuals or couples who don’t require speciality breads, while four-slice models are perfect for families or those who enjoy a leisurely breakfast with eggs on toast. Many brands design two- and four-slice toaster models with similar aesthetics, making it easy to find a matching kettle for a cohesive kitchen look.

Touchscreen toasters offer a modern alternative, featuring sleek designs and intuitive interfaces for a seamless toasting experience.

2. Size & Slot Width

Close-up of a toaster slot accommodating thickly sliced bread

The size and slot width are essential, ensuring the toaster can accommodate various bread sizes and thicknesses. Toasters with adjustable slot widths can accommodate a variety of bread, from thickly sliced homemade loaves to standard supermarket slices.

Adjustable slot width ensures the ability to toast bread evenly across a range of bread types, such as;

  • Frozen bread
  • Thickly sliced bread
  • Bagels
  • Fruit loaf
  • Standard sliced supermarket bread

Consider the size and slot width of your toaster to ensure that it meets your specific needs and preferences.

3. Browning Control

Browning control is an important feature that lets users adjust the toasting level to their liking, offering a more personalized experience. Some toasters provide multiple settings for further customization, ensuring you can consistently achieve the perfect shade of toast.

A two-slice toaster typically features a single browning control, whereas a four-slice model may offer one or two such controls. You can find a toaster that caters to your unique preferences and requirements by considering the browning control options available.

4. Material & Build Quality

A toaster’s material and build quality can significantly impact its durability and longevity, with higher-quality materials typically providing better performance. For example, Dualit 4-Slot Vario is known for its sustainable, quality construction and durability, ensuring it can withstand daily use.

Inspecting for any sharp edges or exposed wiring is important when assessing material and build quality, as these may pose a safety risk. By choosing a toaster made from high-quality materials and with a robust build, you can ensure that it will perform well and stand the test of time.

5. Special Features

Toaster with bagel and defrost settings

Some toasters offer unique features that enhance their versatility and convenience. Examples of these features include:

  • The bagel setting, which allows for toasting on one side only, is perfect for bagels or English muffins

  • Defrost functions, which enable the toaster to defrost frozen bread before the toasting cycle

  • “Lift and look” options, which let you check the progress of your toast without cancelling the cycle

Some four-slice toasters offer browning settings, keep-warm and defrost settings, and even accompanying products like a bun warmer and sandwich rack. Considering these special features, you can choose a toaster catering to your specific needs and preferences.

6. Ease Of Cleaning

Keeping the toaster clean is essential for maintaining its performance and hygiene. Features such as removable crumb trays and easy-to-wipe surfaces can make cleaning more straightforward and efficient. A removable crumb tray, for example, allows for the easy removal and disposal of crumbs that accumulate during toasting, eliminating the need to invert or shake the toaster to clean it.

By choosing a toaster with features that make cleaning easier, you not only ensure that the appliance remains hygienic and well-maintained but also prolongs its lifespan. This, in turn, helps you get the most out of your investment.

meme: crust me! I make the best toast

7. Brand & Price

The brand and price can affect the toaster’s quality and features, as pricier models often come with extra functions and superior materials.

Low-cost, basic models like the Russell Hobbs Futura 2 -Slice can be bought for less than £30.

For those seeking a more advanced feature set, higher-end toasters from premium brands can be purchased for £200 or more. By considering the brand and price of a toaster, you can find one that suits your budget and offers the features you need for a perfect toasting experience.

8. Safety Features

Safety features like cool-touch exteriors, automatic shut-off, and high pop-ups can help avoid accidents and injuries when using a toaster. Cool-touch exteriors, for example, prevent burns by ensuring the exterior remains cool to the touch. In contrast, automatic shut-off prevents the toast from burning or smoking and mitigates the risk of fire hazards.

By selecting a toaster with these safety features, you can ensure that you and your family can enjoy perfectly toasted bread without any risks. It’s essential to exercise caution and adhere to safety guidelines when operating a toaster to prevent accidents and maintain a safe environment in your kitchen.

9. Energy Efficiency

Toasters that are energy-efficient use less power, which reduces energy costs and lessens their environmental impact.

It’s also important to consider the toaster’s recyclability at the end of its life. Choosing an energy-efficient toaster can save on energy costs and contribute to a greener planet.

10. Aesthetics

Aesthetics play a role in choosing a toaster that complements the design and style of your kitchen. Various colours, finishes, and designs are available, allowing you to find the perfect match for your space.

Consider the aesthetics of your kitchen and the style you’d like to achieve when selecting a toaster. By finding a toaster with an appealing design, you can enhance the overall look of your kitchen while enjoying perfectly toasted bread.


Toaster Buying Guide: Summing Up

In conclusion, finding the perfect toaster involves considering various factors, including type, size, slot width, browning control, material, build quality, special features, ease of cleaning, brand, price, safety features, energy efficiency, and aesthetics. By considering these aspects, you can select a toaster that caters to your specific needs and preferences, ensuring a delightful toasting experience every time.

With this knowledge, you’re ready to embark on your quest for the ultimate toast-maker. May your mornings be filled with perfectly toasted bread and endless culinary possibilities!


Frequently Asked Questions

What Is The Difference Between A Two-Sliced And A Four-Sliced Toaster?

A two-slice toaster is perfect for smaller households, while a four-slice toaster offers more functionality for larger families.

What Should I Consider When Looking At A Toaster’s Size And Slot Width?

When shopping for a toaster, ensure that its size and slot width can accommodate different bread sizes and thicknesses, and have adjustable widths for even toasting.

Why Is Browning Control Important In A Toaster?

Browning control is important in a toaster as it allows users to customize the toasting level according to their needs and preferences.

What Special Features Should I Look For In A Toaster?

Look for features such as bagel settings, defrost functions, and “lift and look” options for maximum versatility and convenience.

How Can I Ensure The Safe Use And Maintenance Of My Toaster?

To ensure the safe use and maintenance of your toaster, regularly clean it, avoid inserting objects into the slots, store it away from flammable items, and unplug it when not in use.

Maria Kelley